Secured vs. Unsecured Debt: What Happens If You Stop Paying

Money & Hardship · 4 min read

By · Published

You can find out which kind of debt you have with one question: if you stop paying, is there something the lender can take back? If there is, the debt is secured. If there isn't, it's unsecured. The answer decides what you risk losing and how much room there is to negotiate.

What is secured debt?

Secured debt is a loan backed by property you own, called collateral, which the lender can take if you don't repay. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's glossary describes secured loans as loans in which your property is used as collateral, and says that if you cannot pay back the loan, the lender takes your collateral to get their money back. Common examples are auto loans and home mortgages. The pledge is written into your loan agreement, so that is where to look to confirm it.

The same glossary says the lender can also engage in debt collection, file negative information on your credit report and might sue you. Collateral is an extra remedy, not a replacement for the others.

What is unsecured debt?

Unsecured debt is a debt with no collateral behind it, so the lender relies on your promise to repay. The CFPB glossary defines an unsecured loan as one, such as most types of credit cards, that does not use property as collateral. Medical bills and most personal loans are also generally unsecured, though a loan agreement can say otherwise.

Lenders consider these loans riskier than secured ones, so they may charge a higher rate of interest. If an unsecured loan isn't repaid as agreed, the CFPB says the lender can start debt collection, file negative information on your credit report and might sue you.

Secured and unsecured debt compared
  • Backed by

    Secured debt
    Collateral you own, such as a car or a home
    Unsecured debt
    Your promise to repay only
  • Common examples

    Secured debt
    Auto loans, mortgages
    Unsecured debt
    Most credit cards, medical bills, many personal loans
  • If you stop paying

    Secured debt
    Collection, credit reporting, a possible lawsuit, and loss of the collateral
    Unsecured debt
    Collection, credit reporting and a possible lawsuit
  • Interest rate

    Secured debt
    Often lower, because the lender has the collateral
    Unsecured debt
    May be higher, because the lender takes more risk
  • Room to negotiate

    Secured debt
    Narrower while you hold the collateral; a leftover shortfall can be negotiated
    Unsecured debt
    Wider; balances are often reduced by settlement

Definitions and remedies per the CFPB glossary; examples of what is typically unsecured are general, so check your own agreement.

What happens if you stop paying a secured loan?

The lender can take the collateral, and you may still owe money after it does. The CFPB says that in many states a lender can repossess a vehicle, without a warning or a court order, after you've missed a payment. If the car is sold for less than you owe, you may owe the difference plus repossession fees, which is called a deficiency balance, and a surplus, after fees, belongs to you. Some states require notice first. Procedures for homes are different and set by state law, so check yours or ask a housing counselor.

The mechanics of that shortfall, and how it gets negotiated, are in owing money after a car repossession.

What happens if you stop paying an unsecured debt?

The creditor can't seize anything it was never pledged. Its tools are phone calls and letters, a charge-off and sale to a collector or debt buyer, negative credit reporting and possibly a lawsuit. Winning a lawsuit gives it the ability to use the court's collection methods, which vary by state and by what you own. If you receive court papers, talk to a lawyer or a legal aid office right away, and do not miss the deadline printed on them.

That absence of collateral is exactly why unsecured balances get negotiated. A creditor with nothing to repossess weighs what it may realistically collect against the cost of trying, and a negotiated payment can be the better outcome for both sides. How debt settlement works walks through it, and the CFPB describes settlement versus other debt relief options for people comparing routes.

Which debt should you protect first?

Protect the debt tied to property you can't do without first, then the rest. When money won't cover everything, a car you need for work and a home usually come before credit cards, because the cost of missing them is losing the thing itself, not a collection call. Which bills to pay first ranks them in detail.

Our glossary entries on secured debt and unsecured debt give the short definitions, and debt relief options covers what to do when neither type is affordable.

Where Felix fits

Felix works on the unsecured side: it negotiates with the creditor or collector holding an account you enroll, drafts letters that you read and e-sign yourself, and brings offers back for you to accept or decline. A loan where the lender can still repossess collateral is not what Felix negotiates, and it does not give legal advice. Pricing is a subscription listed in the pricing section, and the FAQ covers what is eligible.

Frequently asked questions

  • Most credit cards are unsecured. The CFPB's glossary gives credit cards as the example of a loan that does not use property as collateral. A secured credit card, which is backed by a deposit you make, is a different product, so check your own agreement.

  • When you cannot pay everything, secured debt on property you need, such as the car you drive to work or your home, usually comes before unsecured debt, because missing it can cost you the property itself. Unsecured balances can often be negotiated later.

  • Sometimes, but the lender has a stronger alternative: taking the collateral. Settlement is more common on the shortfall left after collateral is sold, called a deficiency, and on unsecured balances. Whether a lender agrees depends on the loan, the collateral's value and state law.

  • Not directly. An unsecured lender has no claim on specific property when you borrow. According to the CFPB it can pursue collection, report the debt and might sue you, and a court judgment can later give the creditor ways to collect that depend on state law. If you are sued, see a lawyer or legal aid.

Sources

  1. 01Glossary: secured loans and unsecured loans (youth financial education) — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
  2. 02What happens if my car is repossessed? — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
  3. 03What is the difference between credit counseling and debt settlement, debt consolidation, or credit repair? — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

Written by

Allison B. Money, medical bills, and the data

Allison B. covers household money under pressure: which bills to pay first, hardship programs, medical bills, buy now, pay later, and the public data on what Americans owe.

All guides by Allison B.

Keep reading

More on Money & Hardship

7 guides

Browse all Money & Hardship