Nonprofit vs. For-Profit Credit Counseling: How to Tell

Money & Hardship · 5 min read

By · Published

Ask an agency for your fees in writing before you give it any information about your money. The ones worth using answer straight away.

The label on the door matters less than people think. Plenty of nonprofits charge more than they should, and plenty of for-profit businesses do exactly what they say. What separates a legitimate credit counselor from a debt relief company is what each is allowed to charge, when, and for what.

What is the difference between credit counseling and debt relief?

Credit counseling is budget review and, if it fits, a debt management plan, while debt relief usually means a for-profit company that negotiates to settle your debts for less than you owe. The FTC describes the two this way: with a debt management plan, a counselor sets up a payment schedule with your creditors and you make monthly deposits to the organization, which pays your unsecured debts. Debt settlement companies negotiate lump-sum settlements for less than you owe, often asking you to stop paying creditors and save in a dedicated account.

The tradeoffs are laid out in debt management plan vs. settlement, and the range of options in debt relief options.

Credit counselor vs. debt settlement company
  • Typical structure

    Credit counseling agency
    Often nonprofit
    Debt settlement company
    For-profit
  • What you get

    Credit counseling agency
    Budget review, a possible debt management plan
    Debt settlement company
    Negotiation to settle for less than you owe
  • How it works

    Credit counseling agency
    You deposit monthly; the agency pays creditors
    Debt settlement company
    Often you stop paying creditors and save in an account
  • Fee rule

    Credit counseling agency
    Ask about costs before signing; no charge before work, per the FTC
    Debt settlement company
    No fee until a debt is settled and you've paid under it, for services sold by phone
  • Main risk

    Credit counseling agency
    High undisclosed fees at some agencies
    Debt settlement company
    Credit damage, possible collection lawsuits, taxable savings, per the FTC

FTC, How To Get Out of Debt; 16 CFR 310.4(a)(5).

Does nonprofit status mean a credit counselor is legitimate?

No. Nonprofit status describes how an organization is structured, not how it treats you. The FTC says it plainly: nonprofit status doesn't guarantee a fair price or legitimacy, and some credit counseling organizations charge high fees they might not tell you about. The FTC advises checking the organization with your state attorney general and local consumer protection agency.

The reverse also holds. A for-profit company isn't a scam because it's for-profit. What matters is how it behaves: whether it reviews your whole situation before recommending anything, what it charges, and when. A counselor that says a debt management plan is your only option without reviewing your finances is, per the FTC, one to avoid.

What does the law say about fees for debt relief?

Federal law bans advance fees for debt relief services sold by phone. Under the Telemarketing Sales Rule, 16 CFR 310.4(a)(5), a seller or telemarketer may not request or receive a fee for a debt relief service until it has renegotiated, settled, reduced or otherwise altered the terms of at least one debt under a valid agreement, and you have made at least one payment under that agreement.

For a settlement handled debt by debt, the fee must either be proportional to that debt's share of the total fee or be a percentage of the amount saved, and the percentage can't vary from one debt to another. The FTC states the same rule in plain terms: a debt settlement company can't collect its fees before it settles your debt, and a legitimate credit counselor won't charge you before doing any work. Whoever asks for money first is the red flag. The wider legal picture is in is debt settlement legal, and the cost comparison in debt settlement companies vs. doing it yourself.

How do you find an approved credit counseling agency?

Start with the U.S. Trustee Program, the Justice Department office that approves credit counseling agencies for bankruptcy. Its list of approved agencies is searchable by state, judicial district and language, and individuals must complete counseling from one of them before they're eligible to file for bankruptcy.

Two cautions. The list exists for the bankruptcy requirement, so it's the right place to find a counselor for that step, not a guarantee about every other service an agency sells. And an agency's appearance on it doesn't replace the questions below.

What to ask before you sign anything
  • What will every fee be?

    Get setup and monthly fees in writing. A legitimate counselor gives you a quote.

  • Do you review my whole budget first?

    Be wary of anyone who recommends one plan before looking at your finances.

  • Do you charge before doing any work?

    Neither a counselor nor, for phone sales, a settlement company should.

  • Which creditors have agreed to the plan?

    Confirm with each creditor before your first payment.

  • What will you do if I can't afford your fees?

    Ask directly, and check the answer with your state attorney general.

If a creditor or collector has already sued you, don't miss the deadline on your court papers. Talk to a lawyer or your local legal aid office before you sign up with any agency or company.

Where does Felix fit?

Felix is not a credit counselor, doesn't run debt management plans and isn't a debt settlement company that holds your money. It's a subscription for negotiating eligible unsecured debts on the settlement side: it drafts a first-person letter in your name that you read and e-sign before it's mailed from your own address. The price is on the pricing section before you enroll, with no percentage of your debt, and the FAQ covers what's in scope. If a debt management plan fits your situation, a counselor is the better place to start.

Frequently asked questions

  • No. The FTC says nonprofit status doesn't guarantee a fair price or legitimacy, and that some credit counseling organizations charge high fees they may not tell you about. Check the organization with your state attorney general and local consumer protection agency, and get the fee quote in writing.

  • Not for services sold by phone. Under the FTC's Telemarketing Sales Rule, 16 CFR 310.4(a)(5), a seller can't collect a fee until it has settled or changed the terms of at least one debt and you have made at least one payment under that agreement.

  • Yes. The U.S. Trustee Program says individuals must complete credit counseling from an approved agency before they are eligible to file. Its list, searchable by state and district, is at justice.gov/ust. Use that list rather than an agency you found through an ad.

  • Ask what every fee will be and get it in writing, whether they review your whole budget before recommending a plan, whether you can get help if you can't pay, and which creditors have agreed to any plan before you pay anything. A counselor who calls a plan your only option without reviewing your finances is a warning sign.

Sources

  1. 01Telemarketing Sales Rule, 16 C.F.R. § 310.4 (abusive telemarketing acts or practices) — Cornell Legal Information Institute
  2. 02How To Get Out of Debt — Federal Trade Commission
  3. 03List of credit counseling agencies approved pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 111 — U.S. Department of Justice, U.S. Trustee Program

Written by

Allison B. Money, medical bills, and the data

Allison B. covers household money under pressure: which bills to pay first, hardship programs, medical bills, buy now, pay later, and the public data on what Americans owe.

All guides by Allison B.

Keep reading

More on Money & Hardship

7 guides

Browse all Money & Hardship