Negotiate and settle
Counteroffer letter: answer a settlement offer with a lower one
Fill in your letter
Fill in this letter with a free account. You'll enter:
- Your full name
- Your mailing address
- Date
- Company name
- Company's mailing address
- Account reference
- Balance they say you owe
- Date of their offer
- Amount they offered
- Your counteroffer
- Date this request stays open
Your letter
Anything still in [brackets] is a blank you haven't filled in.
Read the whole letter and fill it in
Create a free Felix account to see the full letter, fill in your details, and download it as a PDF ready to sign and mail. It takes a minute and doesn't affect your credit.
When should you send this letter?
- A creditor or collector offered to settle, and you cannot pay their amount.
- You can pay a lower amount as a lump sum soon after getting a written agreement.
- You want your answer on paper and the terms of any deal in writing.
When shouldn't you send it?
- Their offer is one you can pay and want. Ask for the agreement in writing instead of countering.
- You do not recognize the debt or the amount. Ask for more information or dispute it first.
- You were served with court papers. Talk to a lawyer or legal aid, and do not miss the deadline on your papers.
What should you check before you send it?
- Check the offer letter for its expiration date, and mail your counteroffer in time to arrive before it.
- Counter with a number you can actually pay. A counteroffer you cannot meet only costs you time.
- Check how old the debt is. In some states a payment or a written promise to pay can restart the statute of limitations, so read the guide or ask a lawyer before negotiating an old debt.
- Keep their offer letter and a copy of yours together.
How do you send it?
- Print the letter, sign it, and keep a copy.
- Mail it by certified mail with return receipt requested, and keep the receipt.
- Do not pay anything while you wait. Wait for a signed written agreement first.
- If they counter again, compare the new terms with your budget before you reply.
- Write down every call, date and name, and ask for anything they promise by phone to be put in writing.
Frequently asked questions
Yes. A creditor or collector's first offer is often not its last, and you can answer with a lower amount. They can accept, counter again, or stop talking, so counter only with an amount you can really pay.
An expired offer may be withdrawn, but companies often make a new one or accept a different figure. Replying in writing before the date is safest. If the date has passed, send the counteroffer anyway and ask for a written reply.
You can, briefly, but you do not need to. If you want to explain a hardship, the hardship letter does that. The counteroffer works best when it is short: their amount, your amount, and the terms you expect in writing.
The letter says it is not an acknowledgment and does not waive your rights, but negotiating can still treat the debt as real. The CFPB says acknowledging an old debt may restart the time period, so check your state's rule first if the debt is old.
Read the full guide: Should You Accept a Debt Collector's Settlement Offer?
Related letters
- Debt settlement offer letter: offer a lump sum to settle for lessFree debt settlement offer letter. Fill in your offer, preview the letter, and download a PDF to mail to your creditor or collector.
- Settlement follow-up letter: ask again when your first letter got no answerFree follow-up letter for a debt settlement or hardship request that went unanswered. Restate your request, ask for a reply and download a PDF.
- Final settlement offer letter: your last, best offer with a clear deadlineFree final settlement offer letter. State your last lump-sum offer and a response date, preview the letter and download a PDF.
Sources
- How do I negotiate a settlement with a debt collector? (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau)
- What is a statute of limitations on a debt? (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau)
