Leer en español

Lawsuits and court

Affirmative defense: what it means

In a debt lawsuit, an affirmative defense is something you raise yourself. Rather than just denying the collector's claim, you assert a separate reason it should not win, and you carry the burden of showing it applies.

A common example in debt cases is that the statute of limitations has run out. Courts generally do not apply it on their own, so it works only if it is raised, usually in the answer. Which defenses count as affirmative can vary by jurisdiction.

The common mistake is not responding at all, which forfeits the chance to raise any defense and can lead to a default judgment. Another is assuming a good defense will be noticed without being stated.

Whether a defense fits your facts is a legal question. Talk to a lawyer or legal aid office, and do it before the response deadline on your summons.

Example

A woman is sued by Cavalry SPV over a credit card she last paid on years ago. In her answer she raises the statute of limitations as an affirmative defense, so the court can consider whether the debt is time-barred.

Go further

Frequently asked questions

  • In many places, yes. It generally must be raised in your answer, because courts typically do not apply it automatically. Rules differ by state, so ask a lawyer or legal aid office how it works in your court.

  • You may lose the chance to use it. If you do not respond at all, the court can enter a default judgment. Raising defenses on time, in the format your court requires, is what keeps them available.

Sources