New York · Sued for a debt
Sued for a debt in New York: deadlines and courts
New York at a glance
- City courts and town and village justice courts (outside New York City)
- Follow the date on the summons
- Civil Court of the City of New York
- 20 days to respond
- Supreme Court (county level)
- 20 days to respond
- Small claims limit
- $10,000 (New York City Civil Court, Small Claims Part)
- Deadline to sue (written contract)
- 6 years
What happens after you're served?
A debt lawsuit starts when you're served with a summons and a complaint. The summons names the court and says how long you have to respond. Responding usually means filing a written answer with the court, or appearing on a set date, depending on the court.
If you don't respond, the court can enter a default judgment without hearing your side. A judgment lets the creditor use the court's collection tools, such as a bank account levy or, where the state allows it, wage garnishment.
What defenses come up in debt lawsuits?
That the debt is time-barred: in New York, the deadline to sue on a written contract is 6 years, and 3 years on an open account. That the company suing can't prove it owns the debt, which comes up when a debt has been sold. That the amount is wrong, or the debt isn't yours.
In a consumer credit case, the complaint must attach the contract or, for a revolving account, a charge-off statement, name the original creditor, give the last four account digits, the last payment, an itemized amount and the balance, and say whether the plaintiff is the original creditor. A plaintiff that bought the debt must also give the date of each sale or assignment, every prior owner and the amount owed at sale (CPLR 3016(j)).
A defense almost never applies on its own: it has to be raised in your answer or at the hearing.
Where can a debt collector sue you?
Under the federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, a debt collector may sue you only in the judicial district where you live or where you signed the contract. And under Regulation F, a debt collector may not sue or threaten to sue over a time-barred debt.
Can you still settle after being sued?
Yes. Creditors and debt buyers often agree to settle after filing. A settlement talk doesn't stop the court's clock: the deadline to respond still runs until the case is closed. Put any agreement in writing and ask how the case will be closed with the court.
The courts that hear debt cases in New York
City courts and town and village justice courts (outside New York City)
Civil claims up to $15,000 in city courts and up to $3,000 in town and village justice courts.
The summons states how and by when to respond, and in a case marked Consumer Credit Transaction the complaint must come with the summons. Check the date and instructions on the summons itself.
See the summons; CPLR 3012(a) (complaint served with the summons)
Civil Court of the City of New York
Money claims up to $50,000, including consumer credit cases brought by banks and debt buyers.
Respond within 20 days after the summons is handed to the person in person, and within 30 days if it was served another way, such as left with someone at the home or posted on the door and mailed. For those two methods, service is complete 10 days after proof of service is filed, and the 30 days run from then. For a summons marked Consumer Credit Transaction, the court says to come to court to answer, in person or with a verified written answer.
CPLR 320(a), 308(2) and (4), 3012(a); CCA 202
Supreme Court (county level)
Civil claims of any amount, including debt suits above the limits of the lower courts.
An appearance is due within 20 days after service of the summons, or within 30 days after service is complete when the summons was served by a method other than personal delivery within the state, such as leaving it with another person and mailing it. A consumer credit complaint must be served with the summons.
CPLR 320(a), 308, 3012(a)
Help from the courts
Letters that can help
- Debt validation letter: ask a collector for more information and dispute the debtFill in this free debt validation letter, based on the CFPB's sample, to dispute a debt and ask a collector for more information. Download it as a PDF.
- Time-barred debt letter: answer a collector without acknowledging the debtFree letter for a collector about a debt you think is past the statute of limitations. It admits nothing, promises no payment, and asks for the dates.
- Debt settlement offer letter: offer a lump sum to settle for lessFree debt settlement offer letter. Fill in your offer, preview the letter, and download a PDF to mail to your creditor or collector.
Frequently asked questions
In New York, the deadline to respond to a debt lawsuit runs from the day you're served: 20 days in Civil Court of the City of New York and 20 days in Supreme Court (county level). In City courts and town and village justice courts (outside New York City), follow the date on the summons. The small claims limit is $10,000 (New York City Civil Court, Small Claims Part). Miss the deadline and the court can enter a default judgment against you.
The court can enter a default judgment for what the creditor asks, sometimes with interest and costs added. With a judgment, the creditor can ask to levy a bank account and, where the state allows it, garnish wages. In New York, a creditor that wins a lawsuit can ask to garnish part of your pay, within a state limit that can be as low as 10% of disposable earnings depending on your situation. Before any garnishment for a private debt, the creditor has to sue and win a judgment against you (N.Y. C.P.L.R. §§ 5231, 5222, 5205(l)).
In New York, a creditor has 6 years to sue on a written contract and 3 years on an open account such as a credit card (N.Y. C.P.L.R. §§ 213(2), 214-i). In New York, a payment may or may not restart the clock, depending on the facts. Once the period runs out the debt still exists, but a debt collector may not sue or threaten to sue over it.
$10,000 in New York City Civil Court, Small Claims Part. Many credit card and medical debt claims fall under that amount, so debt cases are often filed there.
More about New York
- Statute of limitations on debt in New York
- Wage garnishment for debt in New York
- What creditors can't take in New York
- Hospital financial assistance in New York
- Free legal help with debt in New York
- Debt collectors in New York: licensing and complaints
- Sued by a debt collector
- What it means to be judgment proof
- Collection agency or law firm?
Sources
- CPLR 320, appearance (New York State Senate)
- CPLR 308, personal service on a natural person (New York State Senate)
- CPLR 3012, service of pleadings (New York State Senate)
- CPLR 3016, particularity in pleadings (New York State Senate)
- Civil Court Act 202, jurisdiction (New York State Senate)
- CPLR 214-i (consumer credit transactions) (New York State Senate)
- What should I do if I'm sued by a debt collector or creditor? (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau)
- 15 U.S.C. 1692i: legal actions by debt collectors (where a collector may sue) (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
- 12 CFR 1006.26: collection of time-barred debts (Regulation F) (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations)
