Credit Freeze vs. Fraud Alert: Which Should You Use?

Credit Reports & Scores · 5 min read

By · Published

If you want the strongest protection against someone opening new credit in your name, use a credit freeze. If you need to keep applying for credit and want a lighter safeguard, use a fraud alert. Many people who've had their information stolen use both.

Neither one fixes a debt that has already been opened in your name. They only reduce the chance of the next one.

What is a credit freeze, and what is a fraud alert?

A credit freeze, also called a security freeze, is a restriction on your credit file that stops most new access to your report until you remove it. A fraud alert is a flag on your file that tells a business to verify your identity before it extends new credit. Both are creatures of the Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1681c-1.

The key difference is what happens to a lender's request. With a freeze, the request usually can't see your report at all, so the application stalls. With an alert, the lender can still see your report but is required to take steps to confirm it's really you.

Credit freeze vs. fraud alert
  • What it does

    Credit freeze
    Blocks most new access to your report
    Initial fraud alert
    Tells lenders to verify your identity
    Extended fraud alert
    Same, plus removes you from prescreened offer lists for five years
  • How long it lasts

    Credit freeze
    Until you remove it
    Initial fraud alert
    One year, renewable
    Extended fraud alert
    Seven years
  • Cost

    Credit freeze
    Free
    Initial fraud alert
    Free
    Extended fraud alert
    Free
  • How many bureaus to contact

    Credit freeze
    Each of the three
    Initial fraud alert
    One, which tells the other two
    Extended fraud alert
    One, with an identity theft report
  • Proof of identity theft needed

    Credit freeze
    No
    Initial fraud alert
    No
    Extended fraud alert
    Yes, an identity theft report
  • Effect on applying for credit

    Credit freeze
    You must lift it first
    Initial fraud alert
    None, but expect a verification step
    Extended fraud alert
    Same

15 U.S.C. § 1681c-1; FTC, What To Know About Credit Freezes and Fraud Alerts.

How does a credit freeze work?

A credit freeze works by stopping the bureau from releasing your report to most new lenders, and it stays in place until you ask the bureau to remove it. The statute says the freeze "shall remain in place until the consumer directly requests that the security freeze be removed." It doesn't expire on its own.

It's free. Under § 1681c-1, a bureau must place a freeze free of charge when you request it with proper identification. It must do so within one business day of a phone or secure online request, and within three business days of a mailed request. Lifting it follows the same pattern: within one hour for a phone or online request, three business days by mail. The FTC adds that a freeze doesn't affect your credit score.

Because a freeze is placed bureau by bureau, you contact Equifax, Experian and TransUnion separately. The FTC's page tells you to contact all three bureaus for an adult freeze and links to a list of their contacts at IdentityTheft.gov.

A freeze doesn't block everyone. The statute lists exceptions, including a creditor or its collection agency reviewing an existing account, certain government and law enforcement agencies, child support agencies, and screening for employment, tenancy or insurance underwriting. It doesn't stop you from getting your own report either. If you plan to apply for a loan or card, lift the freeze first, at the bureau that lender uses, and put it back afterward. The difference between lender inquiries is explained in soft pull vs. hard pull.

How does a fraud alert work?

A fraud alert works by requiring a business to take steps to verify your identity before it extends new credit in your name. The statute's consumer notice puts it this way: a business is required to take steps to verify the consumer's identity before extending new credit.

There are three kinds:

  • Initial fraud alert. Lasts one year, per the statute, and you can renew it. Unlike the extended alert, it doesn't require an identity theft report. You contact one bureau, and the FTC says that bureau must tell the other two to place it.
  • Extended fraud alert. Lasts seven years from the request and requires an identity theft report. It also keeps you off prescreened credit and insurance offer lists for five years. File the report at IdentityTheft.gov.
  • Active duty alert. For service members deployed away from their usual station. Lasts at least 12 months under the statute. The FTC says it can be renewed for the length of a deployment.

A fraud alert isn't a lock. The FTC says it doesn't prevent businesses from seeing your credit report, so the alert relies on the business actually doing the verification. That's why an alert is the weaker of the two tools.

Should you use a credit freeze or a fraud alert?

Use a freeze when your Social Security number has been exposed, when you've found an account you didn't open, or when you simply don't plan to borrow soon. It's the stronger tool and costs nothing.

Use a fraud alert when you expect to apply for credit in the next few months and don't want to unlock and relock three bureaus each time, or when you want the extended seven-year protection that comes with an identity theft report. Combine them if you're a confirmed victim: the freeze blocks most new access and the alert adds a check on whatever gets through.

Child files are a separate case. If a child is under 16, the FTC says a parent can request a free freeze, and it stays in place until you tell the bureaus to remove it. The process differs from an adult's, so follow each bureau's minor-request instructions.

What should you do if a freeze is too late and a debt has already appeared?

A freeze or alert won't remove an account that's already open or a collection that's already on your report. If you find a debt you didn't create, dispute it with the bureaus, put your identity theft report behind the dispute, and read what to do about debt that comes from identity theft. The identity theft debt letter template covers the written notice to a collector. Reading the report closely is the first step; how to read your credit report walks through it.

Where does Felix fit?

Felix is not a credit repair organization and doesn't place freezes, alerts or disputes for you. Those are yours to do, free, with the bureaus. Felix helps negotiate eligible unsecured debts that are genuinely yours, in a first-person letter you read and e-sign before it's mailed. Eligibility is checked with a soft pull that doesn't affect your score, and the privacy policy explains how your data is stored. The FAQ answers pricing and scope questions.

Frequently asked questions

  • Yes. Federal law, 15 U.S.C. § 1681c-1, says a credit bureau must place a security freeze free of charge when you request it with proper identification. Lifting it is free too. The same law sets the timing: placement within one business day of a phone or online request, three business days by mail.

  • No. The FTC says placing or lifting a freeze costs nothing and doesn't affect your credit score. It stops new lenders from pulling your report to open an account, so you must lift it before you apply for credit yourself.

  • No. The FTC says you contact one bureau, and that bureau must tell the other two to place an initial fraud alert. A freeze is different: it is placed bureau by bureau, so you contact Equifax, Experian and TransUnion each.

  • Yes, nothing prevents it, and people who have been victims of identity theft often do both. The freeze blocks most new access; the alert adds a verification step for any lender that still reaches your file. An extended alert also needs an identity theft report.

  • No. Under the statute, a freeze does not apply to a creditor, or its collection agency, reviewing an existing account, nor to certain government agencies and to employment, rental and insurance screening in some cases. A freeze protects against new accounts, not collection of debts you already owe.

Sources

  1. 01Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1681c-1 (identity theft prevention; fraud alerts and active duty alerts; security freezes) — Cornell Legal Information Institute
  2. 02What To Know About Credit Freezes and Fraud Alerts — Federal Trade Commission
  3. 03IdentityTheft.gov — Federal Trade Commission

Written by

Tessa G. Credit reports and scores

Tessa G. covers credit reports and scores: how collections and charge-offs are reported, how long they stay, how to dispute an error, and how to rebuild after settling.

All guides by Tessa G.

Keep reading

More on Credit Reports & Scores

11 guides

Browse all Credit Reports & Scores