You Cosigned and the Borrower Stopped Paying: What Now?

Debt and Life Events · 9 min read

By · Published

The payments stopped, and the letters started coming to you. You signed to help someone, a child, a friend, a partner, and now a creditor is asking you for the money.

A cosigner is a person who agrees to pay someone else's debt if the borrower doesn't. The agreement is real, it is yours, and the creditor doesn't need the borrower's permission to turn to you. This page explains what the law says you owe, what it does to your credit, and the options you have to pay, negotiate or step out of the loan.

Can a creditor collect from a cosigner first?

Yes. Under the FTC's Credit Practices Rule, 16 CFR § 444.3, a lender must give every cosigner a short notice before they become obligated, and that notice says the creditor can collect from the cosigner without first trying the borrower. The wording is fixed by regulation:

The FTC's guidance on the rule says the cosigner "may have to pay up to the full amount of the debt," plus late fees and collection costs, if the borrower doesn't. The CFPB describes a student loan cosigner's duty as "an equal financial responsibility and legal obligation," and says that if the loan defaults, the lender can pursue you directly.

Two limits matter. The notice rule doesn't change the contract, and it doesn't say how a particular lender will act. Whether a lender goes to the borrower first is its own choice. The notice says it doesn't have to, so don't count on it.

Cosigner versus the person who just uses the account

Cosigner

Guarantees someone else's debt

  • Liable for the full amount if the borrower doesn't pay
  • Creditor may collect from you first
  • A default can appear on your credit record
  • Got a separate notice before signing

Authorized user

Allowed to use a card, didn't sign

  • Generally not obligated to pay the balance, per the CFPB
  • The account may still appear on your credit report
  • The account holder can have them removed
  • Not the same as a joint account holder

Authorized users and cosigners are different. See the authorized user guide.

16 CFR § 444.3; FTC, Complying with the Credit Practices Rule; CFPB (consumerfinance.gov).

If your question is really about a card you were only added to, the authorized user guide covers that case.

What does a cosigned loan do to your credit report?

A cosigned account can appear on the cosigner's credit report, and missed payments on it can hurt the cosigner's credit even when nobody tells them. The CFPB says that a default appears on both the borrower's and the cosigner's reports, and the FTC's notice warns that a default may become part of your credit record.

That has practical effects for you:

  • It can lower your scores when payments go late, and it is on your report whether or not you were told.
  • A collection or charge-off can follow. If the account is sent to collection, the entry can stay on your report for the period the law allows; how long collections stay on your credit report explains the seven-year clock.

Check what is actually reported. You can pull your free reports and read the account, the status and the payment history; how to read your credit report shows where each of those sits. If something is wrong, you can dispute it with the bureau and the lender.

What are your options when the borrower stops paying?

You have four realistic options, and they aren't exclusive. The right one depends on the loan, how far behind it is and what you can afford.

Where a cosigned loan can go
  1. First missed payment

    Talk to the borrower and the lender

    Ask for statements. If the borrower can't pay, ask about a payment plan or a pause, and get it in writing.

  2. Still behind

    Pay to protect your credit

    Bringing the account current can keep a default off both reports.

  3. Too large to pay

    Negotiate a settlement or plan

    You owe the debt, so you can ask the creditor for terms of your own.

  4. Default or suit

    Collection, lawsuit, garnishment

    The creditor can use the same methods against you that it can against the borrower.

CFPB, Tips for student loan co-signers; 16 CFR § 444.3.

Should you pay to protect your credit?

Paying can protect your credit, and it may be the right call if the amount is small or the loan is important to you. The CFPB says that if the borrower doesn't respond, you can contact the servicer yourself to ask about relief options. If you expect the borrower to repay you, agree on that with them in writing; it is a separate matter from what you owe the lender.

Can you negotiate or settle a cosigned debt?

Yes. Because you owe the debt, you can negotiate it. That can mean a payment arrangement with the original lender, or, if the debt is in collection, a settlement with whoever now holds it. The general tools in how to negotiate with creditors apply, and you can use the payment plan proposal letter or the settlement offer letter to put an offer in writing.

For a private student loan the CFPB notes that options for leaving default depend on the lender, that some lenders offer rehabilitation programs (which the primary borrower has to ask the servicer about), and that lenders can waive collection fees or reduce the principal balance if you can pay in full. Settling private student loans goes through that route.

Before you pay anything, get the offer in writing and check who is entitled to the money. A settled or charged-off cosigned account is also a credit event, and how debt settlement affects your credit explains the trade-off. If a collector contacts you about the debt, ask for validation first.

Can a private student loan cosigner get released?

Sometimes, and the time to ask is before the borrower falls behind. The CFPB says some loans free cosigners from liability after the borrower makes payments for a set period, and that lenders should publish their release criteria on their website or servicing portal. Criteria differ by lender, so ask for them in writing.

Release is hard to get. The CFPB reported in 2015 that 90 percent of private student loan borrowers who applied for cosigner release were rejected, based on what the lenders and servicers that responded reported. The CFPB's 2014 advisory said many servicers don't tell you when you become eligible, so you have to ask.

A release can matter for another reason. A 2014 CFPB advisory said some private loan terms let a lender declare a default when a cosigner dies or files for bankruptcy even if payments are current.

What if the lender sues you?

A lender can sue a cosigner on a defaulted debt, and the same collection tools apply, including garnishment on a judgment. If you're served with court papers, don't ignore them and don't miss the deadline stated on them. Talk to a lawyer or your local legal aid office right away. What to do when you're sued by a debt collector lays out the steps, and wage garnishment rules explain what a judgment can reach. Time limits on suing vary by state and loan type; the statute of limitations guide explains the idea.

The CFPB's cosigner page notes that collection of a defaulted student loan can include wage garnishment and offsets of tax refunds and Social Security payments, which depends on the kind of loan, so check which one you have.

What should you do before you cosign, or if you're about to?

If you haven't signed, treat the notice as the real cost: you are agreeing to pay the whole debt. Federal law itself describes the signature of a cosigner on an under-21 card application as indicating joint liability (15 U.S.C. § 1637(c)(8)), and credit cards for under-21s shows one place the law requires a cosigner or independent income. If you do sign:

If you cosign, or you already have
  • Read the separate Notice to Cosigner

    It must come as its own document before you are obligated.

  • Ask how the lender handles cosigner release

    Get the criteria in writing and the number of on-time payments required.

  • Get online access to the account

    So you can see payments and balances yourself rather than hear it later.

  • Check your credit report regularly

    A late payment can appear on your report before you hear about it.

  • Agree with the borrower on what happens if they can't pay

    And keep it in writing.

  • Contact the lender at the first missed payment

    Ask about a plan or a pause before the loan defaults.

16 CFR § 444.3; CFPB, Tips for student loan co-signers.

If you've already signed and things are shaky, a hardship letter can ask the lender for relief in writing.

What if the borrower is your ex-spouse or has died?

A divorce or a death doesn't automatically end a cosigner's obligation. The CFPB says a divorce decree or property settlement may assign a debt to one spouse but generally doesn't bind the creditor, who can still collect from anyone whose name is on the loan, and that you generally stay responsible for a joint debt unless the creditor releases you or your former spouse refinances and removes your name. Credit card debt in a divorce covers the details. The CFPB also lists being a cosigner as a way a person can be responsible for someone who has died; inherited debt after death explains who pays.

Where Felix fits

If you're the one being asked to pay, Felix can negotiate with the creditor for you by mail, in your own name, in letters you read and sign before they go out. Checking what you'd qualify for uses a soft credit pull and doesn't affect your score. Whether a particular debt is within what Felix handles depends on the account, and a buy-now-pay-later loan the provider still holds isn't. The subscription's base price covers up to three enrolled accounts, with a smaller amount for each additional one, and there's no percentage of what you settle. See pricing and the FAQ.

Frequently asked questions

  • Yes. The FTC's required Notice to Cosigner says the creditor can collect the debt from you without first trying to collect from the borrower. It can also use the same collection methods against you that it could use against the borrower, such as suing you or garnishing your wages.

  • It can. The CFPB says missed payments can damage a cosigner's credit even if the cosigner doesn't know the loan's status, and that a default appears on both the borrower's and the cosigner's reports. The FTC's notice also warns that a default may become part of your credit record.

  • Only the lender can release you. Some private student loans release a cosigner after the borrower makes payments for a set period, and the CFPB says many servicers don't tell you when you qualify, so you have to ask. Many other loans have no release at all.

  • You can contact the creditor yourself and ask about payment plans or a settlement, since you owe the debt. The CFPB says that if the borrower doesn't respond, a cosigner can contact the servicer directly. Get any agreement in writing before you pay, and tell the borrower what you agreed.

  • Not exactly. A cosigner guarantees someone else's debt and usually gets none of the money or the item bought. A co-borrower or co-applicant shares the benefit of the credit. The FTC's cosigner notice rule says co-buyers, co-borrowers and co-applicants who benefit from the credit aren't treated as cosigners, though they may owe the debt too.

Sources

  1. 01Can a debt collector contact me about a debt after a divorce? — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
  2. 0216 CFR § 444.3 — Unfair or deceptive cosigner practices — Cornell Legal Information Institute (Code of Federal Regulations)
  3. 03Complying with the Credit Practices Rule — Federal Trade Commission
  4. 04Tips for student loan co-signers — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
  5. 05Consumer advisory: Co-signers can cause surprise defaults on your private student loans — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, April 2014
  6. 06CFPB Finds 90 Percent of Private Student Loan Borrowers Who Applied for Co-Signer Release Were Rejected — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 2015
  7. 0715 U.S.C. § 1637 — Open end consumer credit plans (subsection (c)(8)) — Cornell Legal Information Institute

Written by

Daniel M. Your rights and the law

Daniel M. covers the rules that govern debt collection: the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act and Regulation F, statutes of limitations, lawsuits and garnishment, and what happens to debts when someone dies.

All guides by Daniel M.

Keep reading

More on Debt and Life Events

17 guides

Browse all Debt and Life Events